The Valley of Decision

2.14.

Trescorre too kept open house, and here Odo found a warmer welcome than he had expected.  Though Trescorre was still the Duchess’s accredited lover, it was clear that the tie between them was no longer such as to make him resent her kindness to her young kinsman.  He seemed indeed anxious to draw Odo into her Highness’s circle, and surprised him by a frankness and affability of which his demeanour at Turin had given no promise.  As leader of the anti-clericals he stood for such liberalism as dared show its head in Pianura; and he seemed disposed to invite Odo’s confidence in political matters.  The latter was, however, too much the child of his race not to hang back from such an invitation.  He did not distrust Trescorre more than the other courtiers; but it was a time when every ear was alert for the foot-fall of treachery, and the rashest man did not care to taste first of any cup that was offered him.

These scruples Trescorre made it his business to dispel.  He was the only person at court who was willing to discuss politics, and his clear view of affairs excited Odo’s admiration if not his concurrence.  Odo’s was in fact one of those dual visions which instinctively see both sides of a case and take the defence of the less popular.  Gamba’s principles were dear to him; but he did not therefore believe in the personal baseness of every opponent of the cause.  He had refrained from mentioning the hunchback to his supposed brother; but the latter, in one of their talks, brought forward Gamba’s name, without reference to the relationship, but with high praise for the young librarian’s parts.  This, at the moment, put Odo on his guard; but Trescorre having one day begged him to give Gamba warning of some petty danger that threatened him from the clerical side, it became difficult not to believe in an interest so attested; the more so as Trescorre let it be seen that Gamba’s political views were not such as to distract from his sympathy.

“The fellow’s brains,” said he, “would be of infinite use to me; but perhaps he serves us best at a distance.  All I ask is that he shall not risk himself too near Father Ignazio’s talons, for he would be a pretty morsel to throw to the Holy Office, and the weak point of such a man’s position is that, however dangerous in life, he can threaten no one from the grave.”

Odo reported this to Gamba, who heard with a two-edged smile.  “Yes,” was his comment, “he fears me enough to want to see me safe in his fold.”

Odo flushed at the implication.  “And why not?” said he.  “Could you not serve the cause better by attaching yourself openly to the liberals than by lurking in the ditch to throw mud at both parties?”

“The liberals!” sneered Gamba.  “Where are they?  And what have they done?  It was they who drove out the Jesuits; but to whom did the Society’s lands go?  To the Duke, every acre of them!  And the peasantry suffered far less under the fathers, who were good agriculturists, than under the Duke, who is too busy with monks and astrologers to give his mind to irrigation or the reclaiming of waste land.  As to the University, who replaced the Jesuits there?  Professors from Padua or Pavia?  Heaven forbid!  But holy Barnabites that have scarce Latin enough to spell out the Lives of the Saints!  The Jesuits at least gave a good education to the upper classes; but now the young noblemen are as ignorant as peasants.”

Trescorre received at his house, besides the court functionaries, all the liberal faction and the Duchess’s personal friends.  He kept a lavish state, but lacking the Bishop’s social gifts, was less successful in fusing the different elements of his circle.  The Duke, for the first few weeks after his kinsman’s arrival, received no company; and did not even appear in the Belverde’s drawing-rooms; but Odo deemed it none the less politic to show himself there without delay.

The new Marchioness of Boscofolto lived in one of the finest palaces of Pianura, but prodigality was the least of her failings, and the meagreness of her hospitality was an unfailing source of epigram to the drawing-rooms of the opposition.  True, she kept open table for half the clergy in the town (omitting, of course, those worldly ecclesiastics who frequented the episcopal palace), but it was whispered that she had persuaded her cook to take half wages in return for the privilege of victualling such holy men, and that the same argument enabled her to obtain her provisions below the market price.  In her outer ante-chamber the servants yawned dismally over a cold brazier, without so much as a game of cards to divert them, and the long enfilade of saloons leading to her drawing-room was so scantily lit that her guests could scarce recognise each other in passing.  In the room where she sat, a tall crucifix of ebony and gold stood at her elbow and a holy-water cup encrusted with jewels hung on the wall at her side.  A dozen or more ecclesiastics were always gathered in stiff seats about the hearth; and the aspect of the apartment, and the Marchioness’s semi-monastic costume, justified the nickname of “the sacristy,” which the Duchess had bestowed on her rival’s drawing-room.

Around the small fire on this cheerless hearth the fortunes of the state were discussed and directed, benefices disposed of, court appointments debated, and reputations made and unmade in tones that suggested the low drone of a group of canons intoning the psalter in an empty cathedral.  The Marchioness, who appeared as eager as the others to win Odo to her party, received him with every mark of consideration and pressed him to accompany her on a visit to her brother, the Abbot of the Barnabites; an invitation which he accepted with the more readiness as he had not forgotten the part played by that religious in the adventure of Mirandolina of Chioggia.

He found the Abbot a man with a bland intriguing eye and centuries of pious leisure in his voice.  He received his visitors in a room hung with smoky pictures of the Spanish school, showing Saint Jerome in the wilderness, the death of Saint Peter Martyr, and other sanguinary passages in the lives of the saints; and Odo, seated among such surroundings, and hearing the Abbot deplore the loose lives and religious negligence of certain members of the court, could scarce repress a smile as the thought of Mirandolina flitted through his mind.

“She must,” he reflected, “have found this a sad change from the Bishop’s palace;” and admired with what philosophy she had passed from one protector to the other.

Life in Pianura, after the first few weeks, seemed on the whole a tame business to a youth of his appetite; and he secretly longed for a pretext to resume his travels.  None, however, seemed likely to offer; for it was clear that the Duke, in the interval of more pressing concerns, wished to study and observe his kinsman.  When sufficiently recovered from the effects of the pilgrimage, he sent for Odo and questioned him closely as to the way in which he had spent his time since coming to Pianura, the acquaintances he had formed and the churches he had frequented.  Odo prudently dwelt on the lofty tone of the Belverde’s circle, and on the privilege he had enjoyed in attending her on a visit to the holy Abbot of the Barnabites; touching more lightly on his connection with the Bishop, and omitting all mention of Gamba and Crescenti.  The Duke assumed a listening air, but it was clear that he could not put off his private thoughts long enough to give an open mind to other matters; and Odo felt that he was nowhere so secure as in his cousin’s company.  He remembered, however, that the Duke had plenty of eyes to replace his own, and that a secret which was safe in his actual presence might be in mortal danger on his threshold.

His Highness on this occasion was pleased to inform his kinsman that he had ordered Count Trescorre to place at the young man’s disposal an income enabling him to keep a carriage and pair, four saddle-horses and five servants.  It was scant measure for an heir-presumptive, and Odo wondered if the Belverde had had a hand in the apportionment; but his indifference to such matters (for though personally fastidious he cared little for display) enabled him to show such gratitude that the Duke, fancying he might have been content with less, had nearly withdrawn two of the saddle-horses.  This becoming behaviour greatly advanced the young man in the esteem of his Highness, who accorded him on the spot the petites entrees of the ducal apartments.  It was a privilege Odo had no mind to abuse; for if life moved slowly in the Belverde’s circle it was at a standstill in the Duke’s.  His Highness never went abroad but to serve mass in some church (his almost daily practice) or to visit one of the numerous monasteries within the city.  From Ash Wednesday to Easter Monday it was his custom to transact no public or private business.  During this time he received none of his ministers, and saw his son but for a few moments once a day; while in Holy Week he made a retreat with the Barnabites, the Belverde withdrawing for the same period to the convent of the Perpetual Adoration.

Odo, as his new life took shape, found his chief interest in the society of Crescenti and Gamba.  In the Duchess’s company he might have lost all taste for soberer pleasures, but that his political sympathies wore a girl’s reproachful shape.  Ever at his side, more vividly than in the body, Fulvia Vivaldi became the symbol of his best aims and deepest failure.  Sometimes, indeed, her look drove him forth in the Duchess’s train, but more often, drawing him from the crowd of pleasure-seekers, beckoned the way to solitude and study.  Under Crescenti’s tuition he began the reading of Dante, who just then, after generations of neglect, was once more lifting his voice above the crowd of minor singers.  The mighty verse swept Odo out to open seas of thought, and from his vision of that earlier Italy, hapless, bleeding, but alive and breast to breast with the foe, he drew the presage of his country’s resurrection.

Passing from this high music to the company of Gamba and his friends was like leaving a church where the penitential psalms are being sung for the market-place where mud and eggs are flying.  The change was not agreeable to a fastidious taste; but, as Gamba said, you cannot clean out a stable by waving incense over it.  After some hesitation, he had agreed to make Odo acquainted with those who, like himself, were secretly working in the cause of progress.  These were mostly of the middle class, physicians, lawyers, and such men of letters as could subsist on the scant wants of an unliterary town.  Ablest among them was the bookseller, Andreoni, whose shop was the meeting place of all the literati of Pianura.  Andreoni, famous throughout Italy for his editions of the classics, was a man of liberal views and considerable learning, and in his private room were to be found many prohibited volumes, such as Beccaria’s Crime and Punishment, Gravina’s Hydra Mystica, Concini’s History of Probabilism and the Amsterdam editions of the French philosophical works.

The reformers met at various places, and their meetings were conducted with as much secrecy as those of the Honey-Bees.  Odo was at first surprised that they should admit him to their conferences; but he soon divined that the gatherings he attended were not those at which the private designs of the party were discussed.  It was plain that they belonged to some kind of secret association; and before he had been long in Pianura he learned that the society of the Illuminati, that bugbear of priests and princes, was supposed to have agents at work in the duchy.  Odo had heard little of this execrated league, but that it was said to preach atheism, tyrannicide and the complete abolition of territorial rights; but this, being the report of the enemy, was to be received with a measure of doubt.  He tried to learn from Gamba whether the Illuminati had a lodge in the city; but on this point he could extract no information.  Meanwhile he listened with interest to discussions on taxation, irrigation, and such economic problems as might safely be aired in his presence.

These talks brought vividly before him the political corruption of the state and the misery of the unprivileged classes.  All the land in the duchy was farmed on the metayer system, and with such ill results that the peasants were always in debt to their landlords.  The weight of the evil lay chiefly on the country-people, who had to pay on every pig they killed, on all the produce they carried to market, on their farm implements, their mulberry-orchards and their silk-worms, to say nothing of the tithes to the parish.  So oppressive were these obligations that many of the peasants, forsaking their farms, enrolled themselves in the mendicant orders, thus actually strengthening the hand of their oppressors.  Of legislative redress there was no hope, and the Duke was inaccessible to all but his favourites.  The previous year, as Odo learned, eight hundred poor labourers, exasperated by want, had petitioned his Highness to relieve them of the corvee; but though they had raised fifteen hundred scudi to bribe the court official who was to present their address, no reply had ever been received.  In the city itself, the monopoly of corn and tobacco weighed heavily on the merchants, and the strict censorship of the press made the open ventilation of wrongs impossible, while the Duke’s sbirri and the agents of the Holy Office could drag a man’s thoughts from his bosom and search his midnight dreams.  The Church party, in the interest of their order, fostered the Duke’s fears of sedition and branded every innovator as an atheist; the Holy Office having even cast grave doubts on the orthodoxy of a nobleman who had tried to introduce the English system of ploughing on his estates.  It was evident to Odo that the secret hopes of the reformers centred in him, and the consciousness of their belief was sweeter than love in his bosom.  It diverted him from the follies of his class, fixed his thoughts at an age when they are apt to range, and thus slowly shaped and tempered him for high uses.

In this fashion the weeks passed and summer came.  It was the Duchess’s habit to escape the August heats by retiring to the dower-house on the Piana, a league beyond the gates; but the little prince being still under the care of the German physician, who would not consent to his removal, her Highness reluctantly lingered in Pianura.  With the first leafing of the oaks Odo’s old love for the budding earth awoke, and he rode out daily in the forest toward Pontesordo.  It was but a flat stretch of shade, lacking the voice of streams and the cold breath of mountain-gorges:  a wood without humours or surprises; but the mere spring of the turf was delightful as he cantered down the grass alleys roofed with level boughs, the outer sunlight just gilding the lip of the long green tunnel.

Sometimes he attended the Duchess, but oftener chose to ride alone, setting forth early after a night at cards or a late vigil in Crescenti’s study.  One of these solitary rides brought him without premeditation to a low building on the fenny edge of the wood.  It was a small house, added, it appeared, to an ancient brick front adorned with pilasters, perhaps a fragment of some woodland temple.  The door-step was overgrown with a stealthy green moss and tufted with giant fennel; and a shutter swinging loose on its hinge gave a glimpse of inner dimness.  Odo guessed at once that this was the hunting lodge where Cerveno had found his death; and as he stood looking out across the oozy secrets of the marsh, the fever seemed to hang on his steps.  He turned away with a shiver; but whether it were the sullen aspect of the house, or the close way in which the wood embraced it, the place suddenly laid a detaining hand upon him.  It was as though he had reached the heart of solitude.  Even the faint woodland noises seemed to recede from that dense circle of shade, and the marsh turned a dead eye to heaven.

Odo tethered his horse to a bough and seated himself on the doorstep; but presently his musings were disturbed by the sound of voices, and the Duchess, attended by her gentlemen, swept by at the end of a long glade.  He fancied she waved her hand to him; but being in no humour to join the cavalcade, he remained seated, and the riders soon passed out of sight.  As he sat there sombre thoughts came to him, stealing up like exhalations from the fen.  He saw his life stretched out before him, full of broken purposes and ineffectual effort.  Public affairs were in so perplexed a case that consistent action seemed impossible to either party, and their chief efforts were bent toward directing the choice of a regent.  It was this, rather than the possibility of his accession, which fixed the general attention on Odo, and pledged him to circumspection.  While not concealing that in economic questions his sympathies were with the liberals, he had carefully abstained from political action, and had hoped, by the strict observance of his religious duties, to avoid the enmity of the Church party.  Trescorre’s undisguised sympathy seemed the pledge of liberal support, and it could hardly be doubted that the choice of a regent in the Church party would be unpopular enough to imperil the dynasty.  With Austria hovering on the horizon the Church herself was not likely to take such risks; and thus all interests seemed to centre in Odo’s appointment.

New elements of uncertainty were, however, perpetually disturbing the prospect.  Among these was Heiligenstern’s growing influence over the Duke.  Odo had seen little of the German physician since their first meeting.  Hearsay had it that he was close-pressed by the spies of the Holy Office, and perhaps for this reason he remained withdrawn in the Duke’s private apartments and rarely showed himself abroad.  The little prince, his patient, was as seldom seen, and the accounts of the German’s treatment were as conflicting as the other rumours of the court.  It was noised on all sides, however, that the Duke was ill-satisfied with the results of the pilgrimage, and resolved upon less hallowed measures to assure his heir’s recovery.  Hitherto, it was believed, the German had conformed to the ordinary medical treatment; but the clergy now diligently spread among the people the report that supernatural agencies were to be employed.  This rumour caused such general agitation that it was said both parties had made secret advances to the Duchess in the hope of inducing her to stay the scandal.  Though Maria Clementina felt little real concern for the public welfare, her stirring temper had more than once roused her to active opposition of the government, and her kinship with the old Duke of Monte Alloro made her a strong factor in the political game.  Of late, however, she seemed to have wearied of this sport, throwing herself entirely into the private diversions of her station, and alluding with laughing indifference to her husband’s necromantic researches.

Such was the conflicting gossip of the hour; but it was in fact idle to forecast the fortunes of a state dependent on a valetudinary’s whims; and rumour was driven to feed upon her own conjectures.  To Odo the state of affairs seemed a satire on his secret aspirations.  In a private station or as a ruling prince he might have served his fellows:  as a princeling on the edge of power he was no more than the cardboard sword in a toy armoury.

Suddenly he heard his name pronounced and starting up saw Maria Clementina at his side.  She rode alone, and held out her hand as he approached.

“I have had an accident,” said she, breathing quickly.  “My girth is broke and I have lost the rest of my company.”

She was glowing with her quick ride, and as Odo lifted her from the saddle her loosened hair brushed his face like a kiss.  For a moment she seemed like life’s answer to the dreary riddle of his fate.

“Ah,” she sighed, leaning on him, “I am glad I found you, cousin; I hardly knew how weary I was;” and she dropped languidly to the doorstep.

Odo’s heart was beating hard.  He knew it was only the stir of the spring sap in his veins, but Maria Clementina wore a look of morning brightness that might have made a soberer judgment blink.  He turned away to examine her saddle.  As he did so, he observed that her girth was not torn, but clean cut, as with sharp scissors.  He glanced up in surprise, but she sat with drooping lids, her head thrown back against the lintel; and repressing the question on his lips he busied himself with the adjustment of the saddle.  When it was in place he turned to give her a hand; but she only smiled up at him through her lashes.

“What!” said she with an air of lovely lassitude, “are you so impatient to be rid of me?  I should have been so glad to linger here a little.”  She put her hand in his and let him lift her to her feet.  “How cool and still it is!  Look at that little spring bubbling through the moss.  Could you not fetch me a drink from it?”

She tossed aside her riding-hat and pushed back the hair from her warm forehead.

“Your Highness must not drink of the water here,” said Odo, releasing her hand.

She gave him a quick derisive glance.  “Ah, true,” she cried; “this is the house to which that abandoned wretch used to lure poor Cerveno.”  She drew back to look at the lodge.  “Were you ever in it?” she asked curiously.  “I should like to see how the place looks.”

She laid her hand on the door-latch, and to Odo’s surprise it yielded to her touch.  “We’re in luck, I vow,” she declared with a laugh.  “Come cousin, let us visit the temple of romance together.”

The allusion to Cerveno jarred on Odo, and he followed her in silence.  Within doors, the lodge was seen to consist of a single room, gaily painted with hunting-scenes framed in garlands of stucco.  In the dusk they could just discern the outlines of carved and gilded furniture, and a Venice mirror gave back their faces like phantoms in a magic crystal.

“This is stifling,” said Odo impatiently.  “Would your Highness not be better in the open?”

“No, no,” she persisted.  “Unbar the shutters and we shall have air enough.  I love a deserted house:  I have always fancied that if one came in noiselessly enough one might catch the ghosts of the people who used to live in it.”

He obeyed in silence, and the green-filtered forest noon filled the room with a quiver of light.  A chill stole upon Odo as he looked at the dust-shrouded furniture, the painted harpsichord with green mould creeping over its keyboard, the consoles set with empty wine flagons and goblets of Venice glass.  The place was like the abandoned corpse of pleasure.

But Maria Clementina laughed and clapped her hands.  “This is enchanting,” she cried, throwing herself into an arm-chair of threadbare damask, “and I shall rest here while you refresh me with a glass of Lacrima Christi from one of those dusty flagons.  They are empty, you say?  Never mind, for I have a flask of cordial in my saddle-bag.  Fetch it, cousin, and wash these two glasses in the spring, that we may toast all the dead lovers that have drunk out of them.”

When Odo returned with the flask and glasses, she had brushed the dust from a slender table of inlaid wood, and drawn a seat near her own.  She filled the two goblets with cordial and signed to Odo to seat himself beside her.

“Why do you pull such a glum face?” she cried, leaning over to touch his glass before she emptied hers.  “Is it that you are thinking of poor Cerveno?  On my soul, I question if he needs your pity!  He had his hour of folly, and was too gallant a gentleman not to pay the shot.  For my part I would rather drink a poisoned draught than die of thirst.”

The wine was rising in waves of colour over her throat and brow, and setting her glass down she suddenly laid her ungloved hand on Odo’s.

“Cousin,” she said in a low voice, “I could help you if you would let me.”

“Help me?” he said, only half-aware of her words in the warm surprise of her touch.

She drew back, but with a look that seemed to leave her hand in his.

“Are you mad,” she murmured, “or do you despise your danger?”

“Am I in danger?” he echoed smiling.  He was thinking how easily a man might go under in that deep blue gaze of hers.  She dropped her lids as though aware of his thought.

“Why do you concern yourself with politics?” she went on with a new note in her voice.  “Can you find no diversion more suited to your rank and age?  Our court is a dull one, I own—­but surely even here a man might find a better use for his time.”

Odo’s self-possession returned in a flash.  “I am not,” cried he gaily, “in a position to dispute it at this moment;” and he leaned over to recapture her hand.  To his surprise she freed herself with an affronted air.

“Ah,” she said, “you think this a device to provoke a gallant conversation.”  She faced him nobly now.  “Look,” said she, drawing a folded paper from the breast of her riding-coat.  “Have you not frequented these houses?”

Suddenly sobered, he ran his eye over the paper.  It contained the dates of the meetings he had attended at the houses of Gamba’s friends, with the designation of each house.  He turned pale.

“I had no notion,” said he, with a smile, “that my movements were of interest in such high places; but why does your Highness speak of danger in this connection?”

“Because it is rumoured that the lodge of the Illuminati, which is known to exist in Pianura, meets secretly at the houses on this list.”

Odo hesitated a moment.  “Of that,” said he, “I have no report.  I am acquainted with the houses only as the residences of certain learned and reputable men, who devote their leisure to scientific studies.”

“Oh,” she interrupted, “call them by what name you please!  It is all one to your enemies.”

“My enemies?” said he lightly.  “And who are they?”

“Who are they?” she repeated impatiently.  “Who are they not?  Who is there at court that has such cause to love you?  The Holy Office?  The Duke’s party?”

Odo smiled.  “I am perhaps not in the best odour with the Church party,” said he, “but Count Trescorre has shown himself my friend, and I think my character is safe in his keeping.  Nor will it be any news to him that I frequent the company you name.”

She threw back her head with a laugh.  “Boy,” she cried, “you are blinder even than I fancied!  Do you know why it was that the Duke summoned you to Pianura?  Because he wished his party to mould you to their shape, in case the regency should fall into your hands.  And what has Trescorre done?  Shown himself your friend, as you say—­won your confidence, encouraged you to air your liberal views, allowed you to show yourself continually in the Bishop’s company, and to frequent the secret assemblies of free thinkers and conspirators—­and all that the Duke may turn against you and perhaps name him regent in your stead!  Believe me, cousin,” she cried with a mounting urgency, “you never stood in greater need of a friend than now.  If you continue on your present course you are undone.  The Church party is resolved to hunt down the Illuminati, and both sides would rejoice to see you made the scapegoat of the Holy Office.”  She sprung up and laid her hand on his arm.  “What can I do to convince you?” she said passionately.  “Will you believe me if I ask you to go away—­to leave Pianura on the instant?”

Odo had risen also, and they faced each other in silence.  There was an unmistakable meaning in her tone:  a self-revelation so simple and ennobling that she seemed to give herself as hostage for her words.

“Ask me to stay, cousin—­not to go,” he whispered, her yielding hand in his.

“Ah, madman,” she cried, “not to believe me now!  But it is not too late if you will still be guided.”

“I will be guided—­but not away from you.”

She broke away, but with a glance that drew him after.  “It is late now and we must set forward,” she said abruptly.  “Come to me tomorrow early.  I have much more to say to you.”

The words seemed to be driven out on her quick breathing, and the blood came and went in her cheek like a hurried messenger.  She caught up her riding-hat and turned to put it on before the Venice mirror.

Odo, stepping up behind her, looked over her shoulder to catch the reflection of her blush.  Their eyes met for a laughing instant; then he drew back deadly pale, for in the depths of the dim mirror he had seen another face.

The Duchess cried out and glanced behind her.  “Who was it?  Did you see her?” she said trembling.

Odo mastered himself instantly.

“I saw nothing,” he returned quietly.  “What can your Highness mean?”

She covered her eyes with her hands.  “A girl’s face,” she shuddered—­“there in the mirror—­behind mine—­a pale face with a black travelling hood over it—­”

He gathered up her gloves and riding-whip and threw open the door of the pavilion.

“Your Highness is weary and the air here insalubrious.  Shall we not ride?” he said.

Maria Clementina heard him with a blank stare.  Suddenly she roused herself and made as though to pass out; but on the threshold she snatched her whip from him and, turning, flung it full at the mirror.  Her aim was good and the chiselled handle of the whip shattered the glass to fragments.

She caught up her long skirt and stepped into the open.

“I brook no rivals!” said she with a white-lipped smile.  “And now, cousin,” she added gaily, “to horse!”