ONE SOLUTION OF A GREAT PROBLEM
I
The world is willing and eager to
buy what it wants. If you have goods to sell
you soon find your place at the counter, unless owing
to some fault of character your fellow barterers and
their patrons will have none of you. Of course
there is always the meanest of all passions, jealousy,
waiting to thwart you at every turn, but no woman with
a modicum of any one of those wares the world wants
and must have need fear any enemy but her own loss
of courage.
The pity is that so many women with
no particular gift and only minor energies are thrust
into the economic world without either natural or
deliberate equipment. All that saves them in nine
cases out of ten is conserved energies, and if they
are thrust out too young they are doubly at a disadvantage.
A good deal has been written about
the fresh enthusiasm of the young worker, as contrasted
with the slackened energies and disillusioned viewpoint
of middle life. But I think most honest employers
will testify that a young girl worker’s enthusiasm
is for closing time, and her dreams are not so much
of the higher skilfulness as of the inevitable man.
Nature is inexorable. She means that the young
things shall reproduce. If they will not or cannot
that is not her fault; she is always there with the
urge. Even when girls think they sell themselves
for the adornments so dear to youth they are merely
the victims of the race, driven toward the goal by
devious ways. Nature, of course, when she fashioned
the world reckoned without science. I sometimes
suspect her of being of German origin, for so methodical
and mechanical is her kultur that she will go on repeating
“two and two make four” until the final
cataclysm.
I think that American women are beginning
to realize that American men are played out at forty-five;
or fifty, at the most. There are exceptions,
of course, but with the vast majority the strain is
too great and the rewards are too small. They
cannot retire in time. I have a friend who, after
a brilliant and active career, has withdrawn to the
communion of nature and become a philosopher.
He insists that all men should be retired by law at
forty-five and condemned to spend the rest of their
days tilling the soil gratis for women and the rising
generation. The outdoor life would restore a measure
of their dissipated vitality and prolong their lives.
This may come to pass in time:
stranger things have happened. But, as I remarked
before, it is the present we have to consider.
It seems to me it would be a good idea if every woman
who is both protected and untrained but whose husband
is approaching forty should, if not financially independent,
begin seriously to think of fitting herself for self-support.
The time to prepare for possible disaster is not after
the torpedo has struck the ship.
A thousand avenues are open to women,
and fresh ones open yearly. She can prepare secretly,
or try her hand at first one and then another (if
she begins by being indeterminate) of such congenial
occupations as are open to women of her class, beyond
cooking, teaching, clerking. Those engaged in
reforms, economic improvements, church work, and above
all, to-day, war relief work, should not be long discovering
their natural bent as well as its marketable value,
and the particular rung of the ladder upon which to
start.
Many women whose energies have long
been absorbed by the home are capable of flying leaps.
These women still in their thirties, far from neglecting
their children when looking beyond the home, are merely
ensuring their proper nourishment and education.
Why do not some of the public spirited
women, whose own fortunes are secure, form bureaus
where all sorts of women, apprehensive of the future,
may be examined, advised, steered on their way?
In this they would merely be taking a leaf from the
present volume of French history its women are writing.
It is the women of independent means over there who
have devised so many methods by which widows and girls
and older spinsters tossed about in the breakers of
war may support themselves and those dependent upon
them. There is Mlle. Thompson’s École
Feminine, for instance, and Madame Goujon’s hundred
and one practical schemes which I will not reiterate
here.
Women of the industrial class in the
United States need new laws, but little advice how
to support themselves. They fall into their natural
place almost automatically, for they are the creatures
of circumstances, which are set in motion early enough
to determine their fate. If they do hesitate
their minds are quickly made up for them by either
their parents or their social unit. The great
problem to-day is for the women of education, fastidiousness,
a certain degree of ease, threatened with a loss of
that male support upon which ancient custom bred them
to rely. Their children will be specialized; they
will see to that. But their own problem is acute
and it behooves trained and successful women to take
it up, unless the war lasts so long that every woman
will find her place as inevitably as the working girl.
II
For a long time to come women will
be forced to leave the administering of the nation
as well as of states and cities to men, for men are
still too strong for them. The only sort of women
that men will spontaneously boost into public life
are pretty, bright, womanly, spineless creatures who
may be trusted to set the cause of woman back a few
years at least, and gratify their own sense of humorous
superiority.
Women would save themselves much waste
of energy and many humiliations if they would devote
themselves exclusively to helping and training their
own sex. Thousands are at work on the problems
of higher wage and shorter hours for women of the
industrial class, but this problem of the carefully
nurtured, wholly untrained, and insecurely protected
woman they have so far ignored. To my mind this
demands the first consideration and the application
of composite woman’s highest intelligence.
The industrial woman has been trained to work, she
learns as she grows to maturity to protect herself
and fight her own battles, and in nine cases out of
ten she resents the interference of the leisure class
in her affairs as much as she would charity. The
leaders of every class should be its own strong spirits.
And the term “class consciousness” was
not invented by fashionable society.
There is another problem that women,
forced imminently or prospectively to support themselves,
must face before long, and that is the heavy immigration
from Europe. Of course some of those competent
women over there will keep the men’s jobs they
hold now, and among the widows and the fatherless
there will be a large number of clerks and agriculturists.
But many réformés will be able to fill those positions
satisfactorily, and, when sentiment has subsided,
young women at least (who are also excellent workers)
will begin to think of husbands; and, unless the war
goes on for many years and reduces our always available
crop, American girls of the working class will have
to look to their laurels both ways.
III
Here is the reverse of the picture,
which possibly may save the too prosperous and tempting
United States from what in the end could not fail
to be a further demoralization of her ancient ideals
and depletion of the old American stock:
No matter how many men are killed
in a war there are more males when peace is declared
than the dead and blasted, unless starvation literally
has sent the young folks back to the earth. During
any war children grow up, and even in a war of three
years’ duration it is estimated that as against
four million males killed there will be six million
young males to carry on the race as well as its commerce
and industries. For the business of the nation
and high finance there are the men whose age saved
them from the dangers of the battlefield.
There will therefore be many million
marriageable men in Europe if the war ends in 1917.
But they will, for the most part, be of a very tender
age indeed, and normal young women between twenty and
thirty do not like spring chickens. They are
beloved only by idealess girls of their own age, by
a certain type of young women who are alluded to slightingly
as “crazy about boys,” possibly either
because men of mature years find them uninteresting
or because of a certain vampire quality in their natures,
and by blasée elderly women who generally foot the
bills.
Dr. Talcott Williams pointed out to
me not long since that after all great wars, and notably
after our own Civil War, there has been a notable
increase in the number of marriages in which the preponderance
of years was on the wrong side. Also that it was
not until after our own war that the heroine of fiction
began to reverse the immemorial procedure and marry
a man her inferior in years. In other words,
anything she could get. This would almost argue
that fiction is not only the historian of life but
its apologist.
It is quite true that young men coming
to maturity during majestic periods of the world’s
history are not likely to have the callow brains and
petty ideals which distinguished the average youth
of peace. Even boys of fourteen these days talk
intelligently of the war and the future. They
read the newspapers, even subscribing for one if at
a boarding-school. In the best of the American
universities the men have been alive to the war from
the first, and a large proportion of the young Americans
who have done gallant service with the American Ambulance
Corps had recently graduated when the war broke out.
Others are serving during vacations, and are difficult
to lure back to their studies.
Some of the young Europeans of eighteen
or twenty will come home from the trenches when peace
is declared, and beyond a doubt will compel the love
if not the respect of damsels of twenty-five and upward.
But will they care whether they fascinate spinsters
of twenty-five and upward, or not? The fact is
not to be overlooked that there will be as many young
girls as youths, and as these girls also have matured
during their long apprenticeship to sorrow and duty,
it is not to be imagined they will fail to interest
young warriors of their own age—nor fail
to battle for their rights with every device known
to the sex.
Temperament must be taken into consideration,
of course, and a certain percentage of men and women
of unbalanced ages will be drawn together. That
happens in times of peace. Moreover it is likely
that a large number of young Germans in this country
either will conceive it their duty to return to Germany
and marry there or import the forlorn in large numbers.
If they have already taken to themselves American wives
it is on the cards that they will renounce them also.
There is nothing a German cannot be made to believe
is his duty to the Fatherland, and he was brought
up not to think. But if monarchy falls in Germany,
and a republic, socialistic or merely democratic,
rises on the ruins, then it is more than likely that
the superfluous women will be encouraged to transfer
themselves and their maidenly dreams to the great
dumping-ground of the world.
Unless we legislate meanwhile.