There was no Burlingame in the Sixties,
the Western Addition was a desert of sand dunes and
the goats gambolled through the rocky gulches of Nob
Hill. But San Francisco had its Rincon Hill and
South Park, Howard and Fulsom and Harrison Streets,
coldly aloof from the tumultuous hot heart of the
City north of Market Street.
In this residence section the sidewalks
were also wooden and uneven and the streets muddy
in winter and dusty in summer, but the houses, some
of which had “come round the Horn,” were
large, simple, and stately. Those on the three
long streets had deep gardens before them, with willow
trees and oaks above the flower beds, quaint ugly
statues, and fountains that were sometimes dry.
The narrower houses of South Park crowded one another
about the oval enclosure and their common garden was
the smaller oval of green and roses.
On Rincon Hill the architecture was
more varied and the houses that covered all sides
of the hill were surrounded by high-walled gardens
whose heavy bushes of Castilian roses were the only
reminder in this already modern San Francisco of the
Spain that had made California a land of romance for
nearly a century; the last resting place on this planet
of the Spirit of Arcadia ere she vanished into space
before the gold-seekers.
On far-flung heights beyond the business
section crowded between Market and Clay Streets were
isolated mansions, built by prescient men whose belief
in the rapid growth of the city to the north and west
was justified in due course, but which sheltered at
present amiable and sociable ladies who lamented their
separation by vast spaces from that aristocratic quarter
of the south.
But they had their carriages, and
on a certain Sunday afternoon several of these arks
drawn by stout horses might have been seen crawling
fearfully down the steep hills or floundering through
the sand until they reached Market Street; when the
coachmen cracked their whips, the horses trotted briskly,
and shortly after began to ascend Rincon Hill.
Mrs. Hunt McLane, the social dictator
of her little world, had recently moved from South
Park into a large house on Rincon Hill that had been
built by an eminent citizen who had lost his fortune
as abruptly as he had made it; and this was her housewarming.
It was safe to say that her rooms would be crowded,
and not merely because her Sunday receptions were
the most important minor functions in San Francisco:
it was possible that Dr. Talbot and his bride would
be there. And if he were not it might be long
before curiosity would be gratified by even a glance
at the stranger; the doctor detested the theatre and
had engaged a suite at the Occidental Hotel with a
private dining-room.
Several weeks before a solemn conclave
had been held at Mrs. McLane’s house in South
Park. Mrs. Abbott was there and Mrs. Ballinger,
both second only to Mrs. McLane in social leadership;
Mrs. Montgomery, Mrs. Brannan, and other women whose
power was rooted in the Fifties; Maria and Sally Ballinger,
Marguerite McLane, and Guadalupe Hathaway, whose blue
large talking Spanish eyes had made her the belle of
many seasons: all met to discuss the disquieting
news of the marriage in Boston of the most popular
and fashionable doctor in San Francisco, Howard Talbot.
He had gone East for a vacation, and soon after had
sent them a bald announcement of his marriage to one
Madeleine Chilton of Boston.
Many high hopes had centered in Dr.
Talbot. He was only forty, good-looking, with
exuberant spirits, and well on the road to fortune.
He had been surrounded in San Francisco by beautiful
and vivacious girls, but had always proclaimed himself
a man’s man, avowed he had seen too much of
babies and “blues,” and should die an old
bachelor. Besides he loved them all; when he
did not damn them roundly, which he sometimes did
to their secret delight.
And now he not only had affronted
them by marrying some one he probably never had seen
before, but he had taken a Northern wife; he had not
even had the grace to go to his native South, if he
must marry an outsider; he had gone to Boston—of
all places!
San Francisco Society in the Sixties
was composed almost entirely of Southerners.
Even before the war it had been difficult for a Northerner
to obtain entrance to that sacrosanct circle; the
exceptions were due to sheer personality. Southerners
were aristocrats. The North was plebeian.
That was final. Since the war, Victorious North
continued to admit defeat in California. The South
had its last stronghold in San Francisco, and held
it, haughty, unconquered, inflexible.
That Dr. Talbot, who was on a family
footing in every home in San Francisco, should have
placed his friends in such a delicate position (to
say nothing of shattered hopes) was voted an outrage,
and at Mrs. McLane’s on that former Sunday afternoon,
there had been no pretence at indifference. The
subject was thoroughly discussed. It was possible
that the creature might not even be a lady. Had
any one ever heard of a Boston family named Chilton?
No one had. They knew nothing of Boston and cared
less. But the best would be bad enough.
It was more likely however that the
doctor had married some obscure person with nothing
in her favor but youth, or a widow of practiced wiles,
or—horrid thought—a divorcee.
He had always been absurdly liberal
in spite of his blue Southern blood; and a man’s
man wandering alone at the age of forty was almost
foredoomed to disaster. No doubt the poor man
had been homesick and lonesome.
Should they receive her or should
they not? If not, would they lose their doctor.
He would never speak to one of them again if they
insulted his wife. But a Bostonian, a possible
nobody! And homely, of course. Angular.
Who had ever heard of a pretty woman raised on beans,
codfish, and pie for breakfast?
Finally Mrs. McLane had announced
that she should not make up her mind until the couple
arrived and she sat in judgment upon the woman personally.
She would call the day after they docked in San Francisco.
If, by any chance, the woman were presentable, dressed
herself with some regard to the fashion (which was
more than Mrs. Abbott and Guadalupe Hathaway did),
and had sufficient tact to avoid the subject of the
war, she would stand sponsor and invite her to the
first reception in the house on Rincon Hill.
“But if not,” she said
grimly—“well, not even for Howard
Talbot’s sake will I receive a woman who is
not a lady, or who has been divorced. In this
wild city we are a class apart, above. No loose
fish enters our quiet bay. Only by the most rigid
code and watchfulness have we formed and preserved
a society similar to that we were accustomed to in
the old South. If we lowered our barriers we
should be submerged. If Howard Talbot has married
a woman we do not find ourselves able to associate
with in this intimate little society out here on the
edge of the world, he will have to go.”